18+ Party Games

Pick Your Poison Party Game

A would-you-rather party game: choose between two awkward options and see how your answers compare.

Pick Your Poison party game
Players
3–10
Time
20–30 min
What you need
Official Pick Your Poison set, or homemade prompt cards.

Why it works as a party game

A player reads (or the official card presents) two options. The round is done when after a set number of cards, optional high score wins.

How to play

  1. A player reads (or the official card presents) two options.
  2. Everyone points at or otherwise chooses A or B at the same time.
  3. In the official game, scoring often involves matching or dodging the group's choice—follow the box if you have it.
  4. In a simple house version, just debate the better/worse option; no score is required.
  5. Skip pairs that feel too personal.
  6. After a set number of cards, optional high score wins.

Hosting tips

  • The official adult line is Pick Your Poison After Dark from Dyce Games; a family edition is sold separately.
  • Keep prompts within the group's comfort zone.

More 18+ party games